It’s a mostly forgettable season 10 for our favorite turn-of-the-twentieth-century Toronto detective. Here’s our take on this season’s episodes:
- “Great Balls of Fire, Part 1” – 5
- “Great Balls of Fire, Part 2” – 6
- “A Study in Pink” – 6.5
- “Concocting a Killer” – 6
- “Jagged Little Pill” – 6.5
- “Bend it Like Brackenreid” – 6
- “Painted Ladies” – 4
- “Weekend at Murdoch’s” – 8
- “Excitable Chap” – 4
- “The Devil Inside” – 0
- “A Murdog Mystery” – 6
- “The Missing” – 6.5
- “Mr. Murdoch’s Neighborhood” – 5.5
- “From Murdoch to Eternity” – 3
- “Hades Hath No Fury” – 4
- “Master Lovecraft” – 3
- “Hot Wheels of Thunder” – 6
- “Hell to Pay” – 0
At an average rating of only 4.8, this season is the lowest of the series, dragged down by a number of episodes that are competent but uninspiring, and a few that we found entirely unwatchable, with little at the upper end to balance them out.
This season rings in with a pair of 0s in “The Devil Inside,” one more unnecessary slog with serial-killer Murdoch-fan James Gillies, who we thought we were done with for good back in season 7, and “Hell to Pay,” an unimaginative “conspiracy to frame the detective” cliffhanger with the added detriment of killing off one familiar female character and leaving another one in peril. These sorts of episodes are clearly an attempt by the writers to “add drama” and “make it personal” in the most tired and cliched of ways.
Some of the season’s other episodes, though not disastrous, didn’t work very well for us. The period pieces “Excitable Chap,” (4) a Murdoch version of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, and “Master Lovercraft,” (3) about a young H. P. Lovecraft stumbling across a dead body on a visit to Toronto, both have some clever moments but are hampered by poor writing and lackluster acting. The new recurring character Detective Watts is charmingly quirky, but feels more like one writer’s pet project than an organic part of the Murdoch universe.
Besides these weaknesses, though, there are good points to the season. The season-opening two-parter, “Great Balls of Fire” parts 1 (5) and 2 (6), deals with the 1904 Great Fire of Toronto in a way that is both respectful of the historical tragedy and well-integrated into the series’ story and the lives of its characters. We enjoyed the return of Murdoch’s old friend and private detective Freddie Pink in “A Study in Pink” (6.5). Miss James gets to run an investigation of her own in “Jagged Little Pill” (6.5). And there is some delightful nonsense in “A Murdog Mystery” (6), an episode that kicks off with a murdered show dog, and “Hot Wheels of Thunder” (6), which brings roller derby shenanigans to the Murdoch world.
The one standout episode of the season, though, is “Weekend at Murdoch’s” (8), a gleefully silly romp using the Weekend at Bernie’s gimmick in which Murdoch goes to increasingly absurd lengths to try to lure out a killer using the corpse of our old favorite upper-class twit Roger Newsome (of the Mimico Newsomes). While this episode spells the end for Roger, we are happily left with his equally preposterous sister, Ruth, who becomes a new returning character.
Season 10 isn’t altogether bad, but it is a low point in the series. Here’s hoping for an upswing in season 11.
Image: The late Roger Newsome, from “Weekend at Murdoch’s” via IMDb
In the Seen on Screen occasional feature, we discuss movies and television shows of interest.