Season 3 of Elementary adds a new character to the mix, shaking up the relationship between Sherlock and Joan in some interesting ways.
Here’s our episode ratings:
- “Enough Nemesis to Go Around” – 3.5
- “The Five Orange Pipz” – 5
- “Just a Regular Irregular” – 6
- “Bella” – 4
- “Rip Off” – 6
- “Terra Pericolosa” – 8
- “The Adventure of the Nutmeg Concoction” – 7
- “End of Watch” – 7
- “The Eternity Injection” – 5.5
- “Seed Money” – 6
- “The Illustrious Client” – 4.5
- “The One That Got Away” – 4.5
- “Hemlock” – 6
- “The Female of the Species” – 8
- “When Your Number’s Up” – 5.5
- “For All You Know” – 4
- “T-Bone and the Iceman” – 3.5
- “The View from Olympus” – 7.5
- “One Watson, One Holmes” – 8
- “A Stitch in Time” – 7
- “Under My Skin” – 7.5
- “The Best Way Out Is Always Through” – 6
- “Absconded” – 8
- “A Controlled Descent” – 0.5
The average rating this season is a solid 6, which is pretty good and a small step up from season 2’s 5.4. This season continues the previous season’s efforts at threading larger stories through the individual episodes. These larger stories include Watson striking out on her own as a detective and tangling with a female drug dealer, and Holmes taking on a new apprentice, Kitty (based on a character from one of the original Conan Doyle stories). Since one of our few ongoing complaints about the series is the shortage of female characters other than Watson, we find both these story lines offer positive developments, although we miss the Holmes-Watson camaraderie that the first two seasons had built up so carefully.
We are spoiled for choice for the best episodes this season with four topping out at 8: “Terra Pericolosa,” about the hunt for an antique map, “The Female of the Species,” in which Holmes and Bell chase stolen zebras, “One Watson, One Holmes,” about an internecine feud in the hacker collective Everyone, and “Absconded,” a kidnapping case connected to bees. Each of these episodes offers the wonderful complexity and unexpected turns that we have come to expect of Elementary, while leading to a satisfying conclusion. It is also significant that, although there are dead bodies in each episode, none of them is primarily a murder investigation. Not only does this ring true to the original stories, in which Holmes investigated everything from bank robberies to things that go clang in the night, it also makes a nice change of pace from the usual routine of the murder mystery procedural.
While there are a few weaker episodes in the 3-5 range, only one stands out as singularly bad: “A Controlled Descent,” at 0.5. In this episode, Holmes is dragged back into his drug-using ways by a lonely former dealer. While there is something to be said for the complexity with which Elementary handles Holmes’s addiction and recovery, this episode just feels cheap and forced, its dealer character a flat and uninteresting plot device.
Image: Watson and Holmes interview a prisoner, from “One Watson, One Holmes” via IMDb
In the Seen on Screen occasional feature, we discuss movies and television shows of interest.